Episode 572: Junior Detectives

“But it isn’t possible, Julia! He exists by day!”

Tom Jennings — local handyman, vampire, and one of the cutest guys on Dark Shadows — died yesterday, following a brief struggle with a main character. He was 28 years old, not counting the last two weeks.

Now, Tom was a fun character, with family and friends and an entertaining story point and several attractive hairstyles, so we would be well within our rights as members of the Dark Shadows audience to mourn his passing, but it’s just not possible right now.

Barnabas and Julia are as happy as could be, and so am I, because Tom’s destruction means that they get to play Junior Detectives again.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas hypothesis

The thing that everybody knows about Dark Shadows is that it was a slow-moving, low-rated daily soap until the vampire joined the show, and then it became an instant lightning-in-a-bottle success. This is not actually true. Barnabas is crucial to the show’s appeal, but on his own, he’s actually a little bit dull — a pompous, self-involved character who glides from one tepid, passionless romance to the next.

The character who actually brings Dark Shadows to life is Barnabas’ best friend, Dr. Julia Hoffman, who joined the show three months after the vampire’s debut. Like Professor Van Helsing in Bram Stoker’s novel Dracula, Julia is funnier and smarter than the vampire, generates more plot points and keeps everything moving between meals.

But, like Van Helsing, Julia has to stand next to the monster, which means that everyone forgets she exists, and the world is filled with remakes and spin-offs that don’t include her. It’s kind of like if every adaptation of Sherlock Holmes focused on Dr. Watson, and half the time Holmes didn’t even appear.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas possibly

Here, I’ll demonstrate. For the last couple weeks, Julia was under the spell of hottie vampire Tom, which means she got a handful of make-out sessions with a cute boy, and then spent the rest of the time looking pale and interesting while all the other characters stood around and talked about her storyline. But now that Tom’s been staked and the crisis has passed, she wants to get back to work.

Julia has deduced — while on her deathbed, from a standing start, and based on no evidence at all — that the recent vampire attacks are the work of Nicholas Blair, the wealthy and mysterious stranger, who almost certainly would have been named “Nicholas Devlin” if they hadn’t wasted that surname on another character, two years ago.

Barnabas:  Well, he caused Cassandra to die, I’m sure of that.

Julia:  Yes, so am I. I’m certain he had something to do with Tom Jennings, too.

Barnabas:  You still think that Blair made Jennings what he was?

He says this as if it’s been a long-standing theory of hers, even though they’ve clearly never talked about it until this very minute.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas find out

As always, Barnabas does nothing but feed Julia straight lines.

Barnabas:  But it isn’t possible, Julia! He exists by day! We’ve both seen him!

Julia:  Barnabas, I know he’s not a vampire, but I know that a vampire does exist — somewhere, very close to us.

(She narrows her eyes.)

Julia:  I believe that Nicholas Blair is involved. We must find out what his involvement is! We must find the vampire — and destroy him, or none of us will be safe!

And there she stands — the protagonist. She’s got a secret murder lab in the basement, by the way, where she’s assembling a human woman out of leftover carcass parts. You’d think that would be enough story to keep anyone busy, but here she is, poking around in other people’s affairs, and stirring up trouble.

572 dark shadows julia maggie imagine

So imagine being Maggie Evans. There’s a knock at the door, you open it, and this is on the other side.

As a general rule, if somebody who’s smiling like this wants to come into your house for a visit, then you should always welcome them in. There’s no telling what they’ll want to do, but it’s sure to be an invigorating experience, one way or another.

572 dark shadows julia maggie glass

Nicholas Blair has been paying a lot of attention to Maggie lately, and Julia wants to know why. So she’s come over to ask some leading questions, and let Maggie chatter away. Julia cocks her head to the side, which means that she’s recording the call for quality assurance purposes.

Here’s the intel she picks up during this surveillance mission:

* Joe didn’t report to work for the last three days. He’s been standing her up, and he’s not answering his phone, and Maggie is terribly worried about him.

* Nicholas has offered Maggie two thousand dollars for one of her father’s paintings. None of Sam’s paintings have ever sold for that much, but Nicholas was insistent.

* Maggie hesitated to take Nicholas’ offer, because it felt like charity, but she needs the money. Nicholas is coming over later today, to pick up the painting.

So Julia’s got two strong leads here. Joe is clearly another victim of the vampire outbreak, and there must be some reason why Nicholas is so eager to get his hands on that painting.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas gloves

Julia returns to the Old House to debrief.

Barnabas:  Well, was Maggie able to tell you anything about Blair?

Julia:  Not exactly. She thinks he’s charming, but all she knows is that he’s interested in buying one of Sam Evans’ paintings.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas house

Barnabas:  I was afraid your visit would be pointless.

Julia:  Oh, it wasn’t pointless, Barnabas. I did learn something.

Barnabas:  What?

Julia:  Nicholas Blair will be out of his house at five o’clock.

Unfortunately, Julia isn’t holding anything but her gloves, because that would be a great moment for a micdrop.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas empty

Barnabas:  How do you know that?

Julia:  Because he has an appointment with Maggie, to discuss the painting. His house will be empty — probably for an hour, at least.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas detectives

Barnabas smiles.

Barnabas:  Are you proposing that we break into the house, and search it?

Julia:  Yes.

And look at how happy they are. The Junior Detectives, with a whole evening of breaking and entering to look forward to. The game is afoot.

Tomorrow: This Strange Way That You’ve Been Behaving.

Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

During Julia’s visit to Maggie’s house, when Julia says, “Well, then you’d be foolish not to accept it,” there’s a lot of shuffling around in the studio, and the shadow of a camera passes behind the sofa.

At the start of act four, we see the House by the Sea in front of a chromakey sunset. Something bumps the camera aimed at the photo of the house, which moves independent of the background, and makes it look like the house is shifting around.

When Barnabas walks into the House by the Sea and looks into the drawing room, there’s someone just on the right side of the frame who quickly moves out of the way of the shot.

Tomorrow: This Strange Way That You’ve Been Behaving.

572 dark shadows julia barnabas pleased

Dark Shadows episode guide

— Danny Horn

16 thoughts on “Episode 572: Junior Detectives

  1. Not to take anything away from Julia, but I think she did had enough evidence to be suspicious. First off, he claims to be Cassandra’s brother which he can’t be if she’s Angelique. Then his “sister” disappears and he doesn’t seem too upset or interested. Then with his only reason to be in town gone he buys a house and moves in. Plus the odd stuff happening meter ticked up even more than usual even for Collinsport. He looks like a pretty good suspect to me. 🙂

  2. I always enjoy when the show displays its colorfully offbeat sense of humor as in this episode, when Joe and Barnabas run into each other at Nicholas’ house and each tells the other to leave while neither owns the house or has any business being there while Nicholas is out. But they are both drawn together in this situation for different reasons because of what the vampire who hides there has done.

  3. I just have two comments on hair color and styles – first I think that it was a good plot device to have Julia and Maggie portrayed as relatives (Josette and her Aunt Natalie) since they share similar hair color and could convincingly play aunt and niece as indicated in the above photos. Also this is the first time I noticed that Barnabas may be the inspiration for the ‘Bieber’ haircut.

  4. All I can say is, what a fabulous choice of a gorgeous lime green tie for Barnabas to go with that suave grey suit.

  5. I’ve noticed that something interesting’s happening on Dark Shadows at this point with the opening voiceovers (sorry if you cover this later, Danny, I haven’t got to it yet). John Karlen gets a couple and he seems to have an idea nobody had previously: he acts them, rather than just reading them out. He commits to the spookiness maybe a bit TOO much: they sound almost like a parody of a ghost story reading. Then Don Briscoe does one in the same style as his “Cooome to me, Juuuulia”-type lines and then Grayson Hall and Kathryn Leigh Scott both start adding a lot more spookiness when they narrate too. I don’t know if they’re being directed to do this, or whether they’ve all just realised they could make the opening of the show a bit more exciting.

    Thinking about that got me on to realising how major a change it was for the show when Alexandra Moltke started sharing narration duties and they dropped “My name is Victoria Winters”, changing the narration from first to third person. Before that, however insipid, passive and clueless Vicki-in-the-show might have seemed, the presence of Vicki-as-all-knowing-narrator at the start of each episode assured us that she would, eventually, learn all the answers. So, in the early days of the Barnabas story, her commentary assures us that she’ll eventually find out what’s really going on, as she does with the manslaughter charge, with Laura, and with Jason McGuire (though rarely through her own efforts). She’s officially our audience identification figure. But once she’s stripped of storyteller status, she’s exposed as a dull, utterly useless character, and gradually shuffles back into the chorus. By 1968, new viewers must have been baffled as to why she was so import to rate her own special “And Alexandra Moltke” credit.

    1. No, I don’t usually pay much attention to the opening narrations. That’s a really interesting thing to notice, especially if John Karlen was the trailblazer in emotional acting.

    2. That’s a good point. The show should have switched to Jonathan Frid narrating “My name is Barnabas Collins” after dropping Vicki.

  6. I suppose this might strike you as odd, but your brief Holmes and Watson reference prompts me to declare that, on the whole, I would rather read a Watson story without Holmes than vice versa. Holmes, particularly in the early stories, is something of a monster himself. Someone I knew once referred to Holmes, aptly, as the “worst college roomate ever”. Gradually, over the several decades of Conan Doyle producing these stories, Holmes humanizes – largely due, one must presume, to the influence of Watson. I would respectfully suggest that the extraordinary durability of Holmes as a pop culture property, even to this day, is more due to the charm and utter decency of Watson the narrator than the sometimes freakish Holmes. Of course, Watson would not have fit into the Collinsport milieu, as he is not corruptible – at least not easily. Maggie Evans, arguably the one true innocent in the show, would have been safe with Watson.

  7. “* Nicholas has offered Maggie two thousand dollars for one of her father’s paintings. None of Sam’s paintings have ever sold for that much, but Nicholas was insistent.”

    I can’t tell you how much I wanted Barnabas to say, in a world-weary voice, “well, I suppose there’s no accounting for taste…”.

  8. More Julia fashion props: Love the black gloves and purse with the gray suit.

    Julia is all gung-ho about breaking into Nicholas’s house at first, but when they get there she chickens out. Doesn’t seem like our girl. Maybe she’s not fully recovered yet.

    This episode and the next are reminders that Joel Crothers can be really good when the writers give him something to work with.

    1. Julia isn’t wearing a scarf today. Besides the gloves, a scarf was one of her usual fashion accessories. She usually has either a scarf or a high neckline. So that Barnabas wouldn’t be tempted by her neck? To add a bit of color to her rather dull early suits? Because Grayson wasn’t happy with the way her neck looked? Her wardrobe has definitely gotten much nicer since we’ve come back from 1795.

    2. And the last time she wore that suit the accessories were gold (including a handbag I coveted). What an amazing, versatile suit,

  9. I love the way Jonathan Frid pouts the line “I was afraid your visit would be pointless.” He’s every inch the bratty little brother upset that his big sister went out when he didn’t want her to go.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s