Episode 315: Between Sentiment and Survival

“The only possible explanation for David’s disappearance is that he vanished.”

It’s now going on five days since David got locked in a box, and doesn’t it feel like forever? This is something that people miss if they don’t watch one episode every day, the way that the original audience did. And by “people”, obviously, I mean everybody in the world except me.

After all, you’re free to skip around and watch any episode you want. And here I am, committed to this one-episode-a-day format, trapped with David in a secret room of my own making.

315 dark shadows barnabas julia

Still, at least it’s a nice day for it. And look! Here’s Julia.

She’s a little stressed out tonight, because she’s trying to discover a cure for vampirism, and instead of sitting around and being injected with things, her vampire patient wants to go out and kill a ten-year-old boy. It turns out that specializing in make-believe monster medicine has a downside.

315 dark shadows barnabas julia secrets

Barnabas is convinced that Sarah — the ghost of his dead little sister — has revealed his secret to young David, and therefore the boy is a threat to his existence. Julia tries to reason with him.

Julia:  You’re assuming that David knows what you are, but you have no way of being sure.

Barnabas:  Of course I don’t. That’s why I must find him, and question him, and then I’ll know and do whatever is necessary.

Julia:  Oh, you mean if he doesn’t know, you won’t hurt him?

Barnabas:  Precisely. But unfortunately, I’m convinced that he does. He’s been seeing far too much of Sarah lately. Children are always talking with each other and sharing their secrets!

And there’s a nice example of why Dark Shadows is different from any other show on television. Where else would you hear a guy complaining about the social lives of ghost children?

315 dark shadows barnabas julia face

Julia follows Barnabas out onto the porch.

He admits, “It would be a pity if David has to be done away with. I was growing very fond of him. But if I have to choose between sentiment and survival… I’ll choose survival.”

Which is just… I mean… what a completely insane thing for the show to do. Barnabas is now the most popular character on an increasingly popular daytime soap opera. They’ve been working on rebranding him for months, turning him into a romantic scoundrel rather than a bloodthirsty danger to society. And now, just as he’s gotten himself involved in a typical soap love triangle, they’ve decided that he should murder a little kid.

315 dark shadows barnabas vicki

So here he is, visiting the girl that he says he loves, and he’s pretending to be sympathetic as she tells him how worried she is about David’s disappearance. Really, the whole time he’s just pumping her for information. She mentions Joe and Roger’s encounter with the caretaker at the Eagle Hill cemetery, and then he’s off like a shot.

315 dark shadows barnabas caretaker ghost

Vicki said that the caretaker told Joe about hearing a ghostly voice calling for help in the old Collins mausoleum, and obviously Barnabas knows what that means — David’s locked in the mausoleum’s secret room. That’s why he’s heading for the cemetery, because he’s figured that out.

But then, for some unfathomable reason, Barnabas feels compelled to stop along the way and confirm the story with the crazy old caretaker. That unfathomable reason is otherwise known as: it’s a thirty-minute TV show and it’s only half over.

The conversation does not begin well.

Caretaker:  Who did you say you are?

Barnabas:  Barnabas Collins.

Caretaker:  Are you a ghost?

315 dark shadows barnabas caretaker routine

See what I mean? It’s hard to keep the upper hand in a conversation like this.

Caretaker:  You look just like the gentleman in the portrait.

Barnabas:  Please, I have some urgent business and I want your cooperation. I’m looking for a little boy who’s lost.

Caretaker:  And the ring on your finger is the same, too… and the cane.

Barnabas:  Would you please listen to me?

Caretaker:  Why are you getting so disturbed?

Barnabas:  I told you, I want some answers from you.

Caretaker:  What answers?

Barnabas:  About the little boy everyone’s looking for.

Caretaker:  Oh… he hasn’t been found yet?

It’s wonderful, really. It’s like a summer stock production of Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein, where Abbott is being played by Count Dracula.

315 dark shadows david sarah escape

That scene goes on approximately forever, but let’s skip the comedy cross-talk and get to the main event.

David is calling out to Sarah to help him escape from the room, and suddenly, there she is. Ta-da!

Now, I’ve been complaining a lot that Sarah leaving David to starve in the mausolem doesn’t make any sense. (For example, see Monday’s post and Wednesday’s post, as well as the unspoken subtext of everything else I’ve written, said and thought this entire week, including while I’m asleep.)

So obviously it’s a huge surprise when Sarah finally shows up, and guess what, it doesn’t make any sense.

315 dark shadows david sarah nonsense

Delightfully, David treats this miraculous rescue like it’s just another inconvenience.

David:  Sarah! Where did you come from?

Sarah:  I heard you calling for help, so I came to help you.

David:  How did you get in here?

Sarah:  I can get in anywhere.

David:  Well, I’m mad at you.

Sarah:  What for?

David:  For running off, and leaving me in this place.

Sarah:  I didn’t run off and leave you.

David:  Yes, you did!

And she did! Arrgh! The core message of this episode is that everybody in the entire world is incredibly frustrating to talk to.

315 dark shadows david stairs

But what are you going to do? At a certain point, you just say fine, whatever, just show me how to unlock the door, so I can get out of this deserted crypt and go home. I think everybody’s had a couple dates like that.

315 dark shadows barnabas david found you

David gets out of the mausoleum, and heads for home — but he runs straight into the arms of Barnabas, who cries, “Hello, David! I’ve been looking everywhere for you. But now I’ve found you, haven’t I?”

So next week, we’ll get to see what happens when a popular soap opera character kills a ten-year-old boy. Stay tuned, because any minute now, this show is going to start getting a little weird.

Monday: The Big Bad.

Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

Barnabas completely loses track of his lines when he’s talking to Julia in the Old House. Here’s the line where it really goes south:

Barnabas:  Use your head, doctor. I would never keep little David a prisoner, and let — err — let me run the risk of his telling someone about me after he’s escaped from me. No. David… will never. Tell. Because when I find him, it won’t be. To keep him prisoner.

During one of the scenes with David calling for Sarah in the secret room, he lays down on the steps, and accidentally pushes against the step that has the secret mechanism to open the door. He has to close it again and pretend that he doesn’t know it’s there. (This is the scene between Barnabas’ conversation with Vicki, and his encounter with the caretaker.)

Sarah tells David that she’s sorry, and David says, “No, I’m the one that’s gonna be sorry when my family gets me!” Whatever that means.

Monday: The Big Bad.

315 dark shadows barnabas david murder

Dark Shadows episode guide – 1967

— Danny Horn

14 thoughts on “Episode 315: Between Sentiment and Survival

  1. I know exactly what David’s line means at the bottom–my parents would always say, “when I find out the truth about what you did (insert naughty behavior here) you are gonna be sorry, all right!” David means they will punish him for putting them to so much trouble & worry. That is a typical kid way to think, isn’t it?

  2. am i the only person who wants to throttle sarah?!

    after 2 days with no water or food, in a cold crypt, wouldnt david be just a little weak and just want to get out of there asap? oh there i go making sense again! 😉

  3. So the caretaker has (at least) been inside the Collinwood foyer to see the portrait (that wasn’t actually there until just before Barnabas showed up). I bet THAT social call got super freaky, given all the unquiet spirits at the ‘great house’!

    And this is a little picky, but…
    I thought vampires had to sleep in their coffins. Not just any old box, but THEIRS. The one they were interred in. Shouldn’t the casket from the secret room be in the basement of the Old House now?
    But given all the later instances of vampires in the greater Collinsport area who never got funerals, maybe I AM standing too much on tradition.

    It’s the sixties, man, just groove with it, you dig?

    1. Good points, John E.; both about the Caretaker somehow having gotten inside Collinwood to see Barnabus’s portrait, and about B. himself being able to sleep in a different coffin. One wonders now how he came about even procuring the second coffin. Was there a sale at the Collinsport mortuary?

    2. I think you’re ok if you have soil from your grave…which won’t work for him since he’s not buried in the ground.
      I believe they use the grave dirt as a plot point in the Quentin storyline.
      Perhaps being trapped in the mausoleum coffin for all those years was so traumatic that he couldn’t rest peacefully in it anymore. Or maybe the modern one just has better padding.

  4. Barnabas is in the ascension as far as his relationship with Julia is concerned, he handled her here, last time it was her turn, like an old married couple.

    1. Uncle I am going to have to be inclined to disagree with you. How did Barnabas handle Julia saying that ridiculous shit about killing David? Julia was looking at him and probably thought about what she actually sees in this fool talking about killing his little cousin…lol.

  5. I really liked this episode although they’re f-ing up the timeline again (David’s been missing TWO days? Huh?). Mean Barnabas is back and I love him.

    The scene between Barnabas and the caretaker may well have been just filler but I thought it provided a touch of genuine humor, a rare thing on this show. I was reminded of Hamlet’s conversation with the gravedigger although any resemblance was surely unintentional.

    1. The “two days” remark for David being missing mostly makes sense to me. He disappeared in the evening of the previous day. So now he seems to have been gone about 24 hours since evening has come again. But he’s been missing over the course of two different days even though it’s only 24 hours, so I think people would often informally say “two days.”

  6. I think the funniest moment in this episode is when the caretaker gets Barnabas so flustered that Barnabas starts to admit to being Sarah’s brother… then ‘corrects’ himself.

    I also laughed when Barnabas addressed the Caretaker as ‘old man.’ That’s the 200-year-old pot calling the kettle black.

  7. I admired Julia’s temerity in threatening to do away with Barnabus if he harms David. She may be protecting a monster, kidnapper, and murderer, but there’s a line she won’t let be crossed. Barnabus should really think about that; after all, she knows where he sleeps! And their tense exchange gives us this choice chunk of a comeback: “There may be one or two death warrants written, regardless of what happens to David.” Smooth.

  8. The secret mausoleum room has some little mice being creative with stairs.

    When Willie first found the room, there were no steps. Both he and Barnabas had to take a sizeable step to enter or exit the room.

    Then suddenly, wooden stairs showed up for a few episodes.

    By the time David got locked in, they had to manufacture faux-stone steps so the secret exit plot could work. No explanation of who was doing the construction inside the secret room, so it must have been mice.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s