Episode 236: Extreme Makeover

“Vicki thinks it might be her imagination. But somehow, she connects the two… and they add up to Willie.”

Maggie’s disappeared from the hospital! Last week, the nurse thought that Maggie had died, and ran to get the doctor. When they came back into the room a moment later, the window was open and Maggie was gone.

So there are a lot of mysteries going on, and we’ll get some answers by the end of the day. But at the moment, the most pressing questions are: Why is there a camera in the hallway, and why does everybody keep touching Sam?

236 dark shadows touch sam 1

Sam is understandably upset. His daughter wasn’t in great shape when he checked her into the hospital, but at least she was alive and he knew where she was. Now she’s either dead, missing or both, and he’s probably still going to have to pay the deductible.

His first impulse is to run outside and yell Maggie’s name a bunch of times, like people usually do on soap operas, but Dr. Woodard grabs him and says, “Leave it to us,” as if the search and rescue mission is part of the hospital’s quality care initiative.

236 dark shadows touch sam 2

Joe suggests that Maggie may have wandered back to the cemetery on Eagle Hill. He pats Sam’s arm, and says that he’ll go check it out.

Apparently, Sam won’t listen to anyone unless they’re currently touching him. It’s the new rule.

236 dark shadows camera

As Sam staggers back into the room, we see that a camera’s been filming them in the hallway. Is the local news team here already?

236 dark shadows woodard sam

Obviously, Sam is just shattered; he can’t believe this is happening. Woodard responds by putting his hands on Sam’s shoulders, like they teach you to do in medical school.

236 dark shadows camera hallway

Then Burke rushes in, and we see the camera in the hallway again. They cut to that camera for a shot of Burke and Woodard at the door. When they cut back to Sam, the other camera is still in the shot.

This suggests an interesting new way to interpret the show. Maybe Dark Shadows is actually a reality show, and everyone is aware that the cameras are there. That would explain so many things.

236 dark shadows burke touch

By the time Joe comes back from the cemetery, Burke is all up on Sam again. They can’t keep their hands off him; they’re insatiable. Three different guys have fondled him in the last ten minutes.

Burke reminds them that Vicki had a hunch that Willie was responsible for last week’s mysterious phone call, telling them that Maggie was in the graveyard.

Except that Vicki never actually said that. Burke’s talking about a conversation that happens in tomorrow’s episode, and it’s the sheriff who suggests that Willie made the call, not Vicki. They’ve been filming episodes out of order lately, and this is the first sign that the characters are starting to experience some wibbly-wobbly time jumps.

236 dark shadows quad

By the way, look at this amazing shot. The characters are all standing in a line, everybody’s found their light, and they look fantastic. They also did a nice artsy thing at the beginning of the episode, with all three cameras doing close-ups on Sam, Joe and Woodard, and cutting back and forth between them to indicate urgency.

Of course, then they couldn’t quite get the main camera back in focus for the group shot, so you can see them adjust the focus a second later.

But the point is: They tried.

236 dark shadows nurseferatu

By way of comparison, check out this contemporary episode of General Hospital. They start a basic two-shot at 3:00, and they stay on that camera for a full two and a half minutes. The characters walk back and forth across the set, and have six different conversations without cutting to a close-up, like it’s a stage play. They’re finally forced to go to another shot when a character walks through a door where the camera can’t follow.

Meanwhile, on Dark Shadows, they’re making television.

Lela Swift is the director for all five episodes this week. She’s got a silly vampire script, no money for retakes and a daytime-TV audience with low expectations, but she’s still setting up visually interesting shots. On General Hospital, the director just points the camera at whoever’s talking. Swift shows up and actually does her damn job.

And that’s one reason why YouTube only has one General Hospital episode from 1967, and the entire run of Dark Shadows is available on Netflix, Hulu and DVD. The people who made Dark Shadows actually cared.

236 dark shadows burke old house

So let’s go over to the Old House, where Burke and Joe are following a lead. Barnabas says that Willie’s gone to Bangor for the night, and he won’t be back until morning. That might be the least convincing alibi of all time.

But Barnabas says “I find this all completely mystifying,” so I guess it’s not possible to go to Bangor and kidnap Maggie in the same night. What was I thinking?

236 dark shadows come here

As soon as the Hardy Boys drive away, Barnabas calls out, “It’s all right. They’re gone. You’re safe… safe here with me.” And then a hypnotized Maggie walks into the room and takes Barnabas’ hand.


236 dark shadows new room maggie

Barnabas brings Maggie upstairs to Josette Collins’ room, which he and Willie have painstakingly restored. Josette’s portrait is hanging above the fireplace, and there are candles and flowers everywhere. It’s a fantastic set.

“You see?” Barnabas says. “It’s just as you left it, long, long ago. Nothing has changed. Even we haven’t changed.”

Maggie sits at the window. Barnabas purrs, “But perhaps you’ve changed. You’re more lovely, my dear Josette, then I remember.”

The girl reacts: “Josette?”

Barnabas assures her, “Yes… From now on, that will be your name. A name of great beauty. In time, you will learn to think like her, act like her. You will become her.”

236 dark shadows maggie mirror

And there you go. This is the moment that redefines Dark Shadows. It sets us on the road to understanding and eventually embracing this undead monster, and accepting him as the protagonist of the show.

We’ve seen Josette’s ghost sporadically over the last six months; her big moment was in December 1966, when she was the spiritus ex machina who stepped in when Vicki was kidnapped. We didn’t hear a lot about Josette’s backstory, except that she lived in the Old House, she was married to Jeremiah Collins, and she’d died in some vaguely tragic way.

Now the ratings are going up, and the producers need to figure out how to keep Barnabas on the show. This is how they do it — by sticking the vampire straight into the middle of the Collins family’s origin myth.

236 dark shadows dress maggie

Remember that endless soliloquy that Barnabas delivered the other day about the beautiful young woman running away from her lover, and throwing herself off the cliff on Widows’ Hill? That was Josette, and she was running away because Barnabas wanted to turn her into a vampire.

This wasn’t their original intention when they introduced Barnabas. In his second episode, Barnabas talked to Josette’s portrait, and strongly implied that she’d died before he was born. They’re coming up with this plot point on the fly, reaching out for whatever they can use to keep the show going for another day.

This is an incredible retcon, a moment of pure inspiration, and it’s going to drive the story for the next four years. It’s been a slow start, and it’s going to be slow for a little while longer. But this is where Dark Shadows begins.

Tomorrow: Cold Case.

More Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

Woodard explains: “The nurse and I walked into Maggie’s room; the room was empty. And that room that the nurse had left open just a crack was wide open.” He means the window was left open.

Joe comes into the hospital room and reports, “I was all over Eagle. Hill. Cemetery grounds. Nothing.”

There’s a loud squeak when Burke and Joe leave Maggie’s hospital room.

Tomorrow: Cold Case.

236 dark shadows josette room

Dark Shadows episode guide – 1967

— Danny Horn

11 thoughts on “Episode 236: Extreme Makeover

  1. There’s a perfectly simple explanation for all the Sam-fondling; they’re just getting a grip on David Ford so they can turn him toward the camera if need be, or pinch him when he’s supposed to start (or stop) talking.

    1. Yeah. The sympathetic part doesn’t really kick in for a while, and there are ways in which it never really happens at all. “Sympathetic” turns out to be a very complicated concept.

  2. This is a stunning episode (especially the scenes in Josette’s room). One of the best DS periods for me.

    And you’re spot-on again with another observation: Lela Swift does a magnificent job. And hats off to the set designer. Josette’s room is splendid. (Willie and Barnabas sure do FAST renovations and clean-up, though).

    Finally, this new material is just a blessing for Kathryn Leigh Scott. I didn’t know until I viewed the pre-Barnabas episodes starting this past summer, but Maggie was much of anything until now. Now she’s riveting.

    DS had a lot of defining moments, but this one may have been its ultimate. Past, present, future intersect when those two enter Josette’s room for the first time.

  3. I believe that’s a teleprompter in the hallway, not a camera (you can see the script rolling). Also, Barnabas says Willie will be back the next evening, not the next morning (I know, that’s a tiny, tiny point).

    Additional bloopers: In Act I, after Dr. Woodard says he doesn’t think Maggie had the strength to walk to Eagle Hill (Joe wants to look for her there), Sam says, “Well, she had the strength not to walk out of this hospital.” Obviously he meant she had the strength TO walk out.

    In Act IV, as Maggie is sitting at Josette’s vanity and looking into the mirror, there is a shuffling noise on the set, and you can see someone’s reflection moving in the mirror behind Maggie. The camera tries to make a quick shift to the right to block the reflection but is unsuccessful.

  4. So are we to suspect that Barnabas did the Maggie-to-Josette makeover involving restyling her hair from a simple ponytail to the ringlets pulled back with a ribbon? Or did she stop at a hair salon on the way from the hospital to the Old House?

  5. In what has to be one of the most stellar moments of the Barnabas arc thus far……………he physically dictates virtually ALL of the blocking composition from the beginning of the scene to the end by laboriously lighting one candle……………after another……………..after another………as Burke and Joe keep asking perilous questions about Willie making the alert phone call to Vicki the night she first disappeared into Eagle Hill Cemetery. Burke and Joe follow his every move as he candle lights his way and creates an iron-clad alibi for Willie. You can almost hear the director calling out the moves during rehearsal.

    And Barnabas’ evasive delivery on “I find this all completely mystifying,” is simply stupendous. He is actually throwing shade on them by having the umbrage to EVEN THINK that Willie could do such a thing. All of this faux indignation seems to send Joe and Burke packing as they dutifully finish their 5-step blocking process…………..by marching out the front door.

    And Barnabas’ closing line: “And please let me know if I can be of any help….any help whatsoever.” Yeah, right. That ought to at least raise a supercilious eyebrow or two from Joe or Burke. But off they go, into the night.

    And then it’s on to the Upstairs Transformation of Maggie-into-Josette Storyline with what is actually, as Danny states above, a truly remarkable set replete with dresses, the fabulous painting, electric candles on the mantel (must have been short on time to do the natural ones) and……….the Music Box which we will tinkle for us for many episodes to come.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s