Episode 252: How to Ruin Your Life

“I don’t have to think about you. I know we swing, and that’s all I have to know.”

This week, we’re going to alternate back and forth between vampire episodes and blackmail episodes. That means that the cliffhangers can’t really be that compelling — if I can wait two days before I see the resolution, then I’m probably not that worried.

On the positive side, this schedule accentuates the contrast between the interesting ghoulish-madman story and the dull 18-years-ago-murder story, and challenges the writers to up their game on the Collinwood side. And today, they deliver. Let’s meet the new man in Carolyn’s life.

252 dark shadows carolyn liz backacting

The show opens, as usual, with a mother-daughter argument about why Liz is engaged to the shady Jason McGuire.

Carolyn is taking this very personally, and she’s actually bringing some real energy to the conversation. Unfortunately, all Liz can do is keep stonewalling, so there aren’t a lot of emotional places for her to go. I think Joan Bennett looks bored. I sure would be.

Finally, Carolyn pushes Liz too far, demanding to know if she feels any genuine affection for Jason. Does she love him?

Liz snaps, “Yes! Yes, I love him! I’m tired of everyone trying to live my own life for me. And I don’t see you doing much with your life!”

252 dark shadows carolyn do with your life

Which is not the thing to say to Miss Carolyn Stoddard. She looks like she just got punched in the gut.

“Oh, I’ll do something with my life,” she hisses. “You can bet on that!”

Which is a nice little dramatic moment for Carolyn, and I can understand how she feels. But, honestly, what is she doing with her life?

It’s never particularly clear why Carolyn, a wealthy 20-year-old young woman, is just sitting around the house assembling jigsaw puzzles. She doesn’t have a job, she doesn’t go to school, and she doesn’t even have a boyfriend. These days, she mostly fills her time up with fretting, gossiping and distracting the governess. It’s no wonder she’s taken up nagging her mother as a hobby.

252 dark shadows where's burke

Now we get to the moment that I’ve promised was coming: This is the episode where Mitchell Ryan, who plays Burke, shows up at the studio too drunk to go on the air. Ryan was relieved of his duties, and they brought Joe in to fill Burke’s part of the episode. The next time we see Burke on the show, two weeks from now, he’ll be played by a different actor.

Fortunately, this storyline is so vague and dull that it doesn’t matter who’s sitting with Vicki at the Blue Whale. If Joe wasn’t available, she could have done the scene with pretty much anyone.

The one moment that poses a problem is when Joe says, “She can’t be blind to what kind of a person that McGuire is.” That’s clearly a Burke line. I don’t think Joe even knows who Jason is. But the show must go on.

252 dark shadows carolyn buzz

Enter Carolyn, who’s doing something with her life.

Specifically, she’s drinking, and riding around on a motorcycle with a guy named Buzz. Which is not a bad option, if the alternative is sitting around in a gloomy old house, doing jigsaw puzzles and criticizing your mother’s life choices.

Buzz is wearing a leather jacket with studs and chains; he’s got sunglasses and a goatee, and there’s something going on with his hair that I can’t actually comprehend.

“You’re something else,” Buzz shouts as they stroll in. “I mean, you are something else!”

Buzz is out of bread, so Carolyn buys the drinks. She orders a stinger for herself, but Buzz wants to stick with beer.

And it really is a shame that this was the day that Mitch Ryan had to miss. The entire episode is about drinking! He wouldn’t even have to use his sense memory to get into character.

252 dark shadows buzzkill

Carolyn spots her friends at the table, and they stumble over to say hi. Vicki and Joe are not amused.

Carolyn introduces Buzz, and they both stare at her with the kind of frosty glare that you can only direct at people who have had slightly more to drink than you have.

252 dark shadows good times

But Carolyn is keeping up the conversation.

Carolyn:  Oh, I just had the most wonderful day I’ve ever had. We’ve been up and down every road, across every field, and on the beaches. It was living, Buzz, wasn’t it?

Buzz:  A gas, man! A gas!

Carolyn invites Vicki to take a ride on the motorcycle; Buzz is happy to take her out.

Vicki responds by looking at them like this:

252 dark shadows vicki not amused

And apparently we’re supposed to think that Vicki is being patient and noble, and that Carolyn is out of line.

That is not my assessment of the situation. I think that Carolyn’s had another in a long series of stressful weeks, and now she’s spending a pleasant evening out with an agreeable and attentive young man.

Vicki and Joe need to lighten the hell up.

252 dark shadows make out

And look at what a gentleman he is — he drives his motorcycle all the way up to the front door! She wants to keep riding, but he peels her off the bike, saying, “You’ve had enough for one day.”

(Note: Buzz is moderate and responsible.)

They make out a little bit, but after a minute, he slows things down: “Hey, hey, cool it, cool it! The world’s not coming to an end.”

(Note: Buzz is mindful about taking advantage of a girl who’s had too much to drink.)

She asks, “Buzz, what do you think of me?”

“I don’t have to think about you,” he says. “I know we swing, and that’s all I have to know.”

Which is clearly the right answer. How awesome is Buzz? He’s marriage material.

252 dark shadows stairs

She invites him in, and he’s impressed.

Buzz:  People live in this place?

Carolyn:  Not really. It’s the kind of place people exist in.

He jokes, “See those stairs! I’d like to take my bike and zoom right up it!” She thinks that’s hilarious; she says they should go bring the bike in and try it out.

Once again, Buzz is the moderate voice: “Cool it! I don’t want to bring in my bike and wake everyone up. I don’t want to get kicked out of here.” (Note: Concerned about others.)

252 dark shadows buzz dont dance

There’s only one area where I think Buzz could use some constructive criticism, namely: He doesn’t dance.

Carolyn puts on some music and starts thrashing around. Buzz does a couple steps, but then he sits down and just snaps his fingers. I think Buzz could work on coming out of his shell a little more.

252 dark shadows buzz date night

The party is interrupted by Liz, who’s come all the way downstairs to tell them that it’s three o’clock in the morning, even though there’s a perfectly good clock in the foyer that they could have consulted if they were curious about the current time.

Carolyn says, “Heyyy, it’s Mommy! I want you to meet my man. A real man. His name is Buzz.”

Buzz gives her a wave: “Hiya, Mommy.” (Note: Friendly, approachable, makes a gently satirical comment on social norms.)

Liz snaps, “You’d better get out of here,” which is simply rude.

Buzz objects, “I mean, like wait a minute now, Mrs. Stoddard,” and you have to admit that he’s got a point.

252 dark shadows buzz carolyn liz

Carolyn snuggles up, and corrects him: “Why are you calling her Mrs. Stoddard? It’s Mrs. McGuire.”

She explains that Liz is going to marry Jason McGuire, so she’s going to have a brand new name.

252 dark shadows carolyn mommy

“Figures,” Buzz says. “So why are you calling her that now?”

Carolyn turns on Liz.

Carolyn:  Because I want her to get used to it. I want her to know how it feels to be Mrs. Jason McGuire. I want her to be proud of the name! You are proud of it, aren’t you? Mrs. McGuire?

252 dark shadows mrs mcguire
Liz has nothing to say; she turns and walks out. Carolyn follows her into the foyer:

Carolyn:  What’s the matter, Mrs. McGuire? Don’t you like your new name?

She pounds on the table.

Carolyn:  Mrs. McGuire! Mrs. McGuire! MRS. MCGUIRE!

252 dark shadows have you found love

Liz pauses on the landing, as her daughter shrieks:

Carolyn:  So you’ve found LOVE, Mrs. McGuire? Well, SO HAVE I !

252 dark shadows kiss

And Carolyn throws herself into Buzz’s arms for a passionate kiss.

Horrified, Liz turns to open the landing door…

252 dark shadows door problems

And the door is stuck. She can’t get it open. She struggles with the doorknob as the scene fades out. Which makes this one of the all-time great scenes of television.

Tomorrow: Alive and Someplace.

252 dark shadows foyer drunk

Dark Shadows episode guide – 1967

— Danny Horn

12 thoughts on “Episode 252: How to Ruin Your Life

    1. Follow Literary License Podcast on most apps inc YouTube. Michael Hadge, who played Buzz, has agreed to interview. He is now 87 and lives on the East Coast, writing a play. We plan at this point to have him on last Fri in May or last Fri in June during regular episode recap. He never attended cons, has infrequently talked about DS, so this will be a first.

  1. LOVE the ending scene with Carolyn shrieking “Mrs. McGuire” over and over as the usually in-control Liz flees up the stairs. The stuck door just made it all the better.

    I know the Basement Storyline is plodding at times, but I kind of like this period of DS when there are things both natural and supernatural upsetting the household.

  2. It would have been funny if Liz was still struggling with that door as the credits rolled.

  3. It’s nice to see finally a proper appreciation of Buzz, one of the most interesting and colorful figures to grace the foyer. Anyone who combined some of the more memorable traits of Maynard G. Krebs and Dennis Hopper deserved a far better fate than the unceremonious last appearance he got.

    btw, it’s interesting that during the time of these eps, the Summer of Love, Collinsporters were still so far behind the cultural curve that beatniks were the most outre sort they could cultivate. Although given the way hippies were treated elsewhere on TV (I’m looking at you, Paul Henning), this is probably a good thing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s