Episode 859: If I Were You

“Oh? And what a strange suicide that would be!”

Fridays have always been fairly freaky on Dark Shadows, but this week they’ve upped the ante with a body swap story featuring the mad wizard Count Petofi’s hostile takeover of teen idol pop star Quentin Collins’ body. Petofi claims that he’s stolen his co-star’s face because he wants to escape from a pack of gypsies baying for his blood, but I think there are some other things at play. I know what I’d do if I suddenly looked like Quentin Collins, and I wouldn’t be wasting my time researching I Ching hexagrams.

But body swap stories tend to be light on the benefits and heavy on the downsides, a way to explain and reaffirm the status quo as the best of all possible worlds. This goes back to the first example of the trope, an 1882 comic novel called Vice Versa.

I’ve been reading Vice Versa lately, and it’s pretty funny. It’s about a pompous English businessman named Paul Bultitude who can’t stand children, up to and including his own son Dick. In the opening chapter, the winter holidays are over, and the boy’s about to go back to boarding school. Dick isn’t looking forward to it, so Mr. Bultitude delivers a pompous lecture about the joys of school and boyhood, ending with a wish that he was a boy again.

As it happens, Bultitude is holding a magic stone that his brother-in-law brought back from India, a region with a high rate of magic stones per capita. His wish is granted, and he’s turned into a perfect duplicate of his son. Delighted at the chance to skip school, Dick wishes himself into his father’s body, and then sends his perplexed dad off in his place.

The novel follows Mr. Bultitude through a very uncomfortable week at his son’s terrible punishment school. He tries to act like the mature gentleman that he is, in order to demonstrate that he’s not actually Dick — which gets him bullied by the other boys, persecuted by the headmaster, and generally ill-treated by everyone.

I haven’t finished the book yet, but I assume that it ends with father and son going back to their own bodies, wiser for their experiences, and then they go and burn down the school, to the delight of all. That’s the point of body swap stories, seeing the world from the other person’s point of view, and learning to appreciate other people’s perspectives. Except for the movie Face/Off, of course, which is about figuring out whether it’s better to be born looking like Nicolas Cage, or to be born as somebody else and become Nicolas Cage later on in life.

859 dark shadows kitty petofi mad

So far, Quentin’s transformation has been nothing but downsides, because he’s been tricked into inhabiting a body that’s relentlessly pissed people off for more than a hundred years. He doesn’t have the power of the Legendary Hand of Count Petofi — Petofi took the legendary part with him, leaving Quentin with a fistful of useless fingers — but he’s still got all of Petofi’s enemies and detractors.

At the end of yesterday’s episode, Quentin had just managed to find the one person in the world who would believe his unlikely story — the eminent Dr. Julia Hoffman, temporarily tumbled down the rabbit-hole and willing to believe just about anything — when the wound she’d made in the time-space continuum reopened, pulling her back to her proper place in history.

And now, to add insult to injury, Lady Kitty Hampshire rolls in and accuses him of causing her recent Josette-related fugue states, which aren’t even Petofi’s fault, much less Quentin’s. Quentin hardly even knows this broad. But you kill one unicorn in this town, and you’re on the most-wanted list for life; that’s just the way it is.

859 dark shadows quentin kitty behavior

Quentin’s protestations of innocence just infuriate Kitty, who dares him to deny what he did to her husband, when they knew each other in England several years ago. Quentin has no idea what she’s talking about, but her recital of grievances gives him his first decent idea of the week.

“I can’t convince her,” he muses in thinks, “but if I can’t… can I use her? If she thinks I am Petofi, and if she knew him before, then she must have known his powers — and been afraid of him!”

So he straightens his tie, and smiles at her, and delivers his best Petofi impression. “How wise you are, for one so beautiful, Lady Hampshire!” he cries, taking a moment to relish the weird irony of his imposture. And she falls for it, obviously, because she already thought he was Petofi in the first place. All he has to do is relax, and stop denying what everyone else already knows is true.

Kitty continues to pile more accusations on top of each other, and look how delighted Quentin is; he’s beaming. That’s the look of a man who’s finally found an angle.

859 dark shadows kitty threatened

The key to surviving in Count Petofi’s body is to actually become Count Petofi, to stop struggling against the current and use the powers available to him. In his own body, Quentin had some tricks that he simply can’t play anymore– like seducing someone, or threatening physical violence, which he can’t pull off in this unwanted new suit. But he can use the resentment and the fear that Petofi has earned, and that’s something.

If he has any hope of getting some leverage on Petofi, he needs access to the magical portrait, which grants the immortality that Petofi’s time travel scheme requires. So he threatens Kitty, using a Legendary Hand that she doesn’t realize is currently shooting blanks.

“I will do nothing for you!” Kitty declares, but Quentin was hoping for an opening like that.

“But you will, my dear,” he rumbles, in a tone that stops her in her tracks. “Or you will disappear, as poor Julia did!” He brandishes the Legendary H. “You remember this Hand, Lady Hampshire! Look at it. It has certain powers… if I pass it over your face, you will disappear. Shall I prove it to you?”

It’s the curse of a child — I’ll wave my hand, and make you disappear! — but it gets the job done, and Quentin takes a step towards becoming the enemy that he despises.

859 dark shadows quentin edward eyebrow

Meanwhile, Count Petofi is getting comfortable in his stolen property, to the point that he’s even willing to make jokes about it.

Edward:  Perhaps the best thing is to forget what Barnabas Collins was. He’s merely an ancestor, now.

Petofi:  No better and no worse than some of the others.

Edward:  How can you say that?

Petofi:  I’m a realist, Edward; I believe in being honest.

Edward:  Throughout your life, you’ve managed to conceal that fact very well.

Petofi:  (raising an eyebrow) Ah… but I’ve changed, Edward.

That’s rather bold; it was only a few days ago that Petofi was worried that someone might see through his charade. Now, he’s waggishly drawing attention to it.

Although I suppose that’s typical for Quentin, the mercurial trickster. All the way back in the first episode in 1897, he shrugged off his grandmother’s suggestion that he was like the Tower of Destruction, the worst card in the Tarot deck.

“This card always has the same picture,” he pointed out. “People change.” And he’s changed a dozen times since then, taking on new roles and discarding the old. Lover, cheater, liar, monster — and then, somehow, the family protector. Subletting his body to a new occupant is just another turn of the wheel.

859 dark shadows edward quentin turn

But the tables turn again, and Petofi finds himself in one of those body-swap downsides. Kitty returns to Collinwood and reports that the odd woman who’d been staying at the rectory has disappeared — and when Edward finds out that the mysterious woman who appeared on his doorstep last month was living on-property all this time, he heads out to investigate.

When Edward finds his little brother already on the premises, he jumps right back into their childhood squabbles.

“You’re somehow involved in this, Quentin!” Edward cries. “Who is this woman? How do you know her? Where is she? I want answers, Quentin, truthful answers!”

Using Quentin’s eyes, Petofi frowns. “You never change, will you, Edward? Anything you don’t understand, you blame on me!”

And that’s a weird moment. Count Petofi should be delighted that his masquerade is working so well, the way that Quentin was, when he realized that he could frighten Lady Hampshire. Upsetting Edward is just another testament to Petofi’s success; making Edward suspicious is the least suspicious thing that “Quentin” can do.

But he doesn’t see it that way. In the heat of this particular moment, Petofi experiences one of Quentin’s longstanding frustrations, and he reacts as Quentin would, with no irony intended. Petofi is learning to be Quentin, just as Quentin is learning to be Petofi, and — as I’ve wondered all week — maybe there wasn’t that much difference between them in the first place.

859 dark shadows quentin petofi hostile

There’s another revealing encounter later on in the episode, when Quentin returns to the rectory, and finds Petofi there. Things start out on a relatively light note.

Petofi:  So you’ve come back, huh?

Quentin:  I would not have come, if I’d known you were here.

Petofi:  I should think that you’d enjoy seeing me. Most people want to see themselves, as others see them.

Quentin:  I could kill you…

Petofi:  Oh? And what a strange suicide that would be! The man who killed himself, remained alive in another body!

859 dark shadows quentin petofi mad

But that only lasts for a moment, before Petofi’s mood grows darker.

“You will not get away with this,” Quentin warns, and Petofi flares up.

“You go tell your sad story to someone else,” he hisses. “There’s nothing you can do. No one would believe you! You are nothing but a senile old man, raving mad! Now run along, my boy.”

And I think that’s key to what’s happening here: Petofi’s fury, unable to stand being in the same room with the man that he used to be.

The harmless body-swap comedy of Vice Versa and Freaky Friday hinges on the idea that you should be satisfied with what you are. The adult can’t live in a body that doesn’t have a driver’s license, and the child isn’t ready for grown-up responsibilities. The prince wants to reclaim his throne, and the pauper is happy to escape the grinding courtesies of the royal court. Dorothy remembers that there’s no place like home, and Alice realizes that the Queen’s soldiers are just a pack of cards, and everybody returns happily to their proper place.

But this isn’t a midsummer night’s dream for Count Petofi. He didn’t leave his body by accident; it was an escape plan, and he’s damned if he’ll return to the prison of his old flesh. Seeing himself now, as others saw him, he realizes how feeble and odd he looked, and it repels him. Petofi’s dream — to escape his body, to escape his life — it’s fueled by self-hatred. He looks at himself, and feels nothing but contempt.

For all of his proclamations about the Legend of Petofi, about his power and cunning and exquisite taste, the mad god actually despised himself, and longed for a way out. That’s often the case, that the people who endlessly brag about themselves are over-compensating for the inadequacies that they know only too well. That’s what makes them so spiteful, and dangerous. Luckily, there’s nobody of any importance in American public life who acts like that, so it’s not like it really matters.

Tomorrow: Mesa of Lost Women.

Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

Quentin terrorizes Kitty by reminding her of the powers in Petofi’s magical Hand — but when Kitty knew Petofi in England, he didn’t have the Hand at the time.

When Edward moves to embrace Kitty in act two, he says, “Katie, you can’t go on like this!”

In the rectory during the third act, the camera pulls back, trying to track Petofi as he walks away from a two-shot with Quentin, and approaches the door. But there are candles in the way of the shot, so the camera tilts up a bit, trying to get the candles out of the frame. The result is a really odd shot, with the actors seen from shoulders up in the bottom half of the screen.

In the rectory, Petofi finds the clothes that Julia was wearing when she arrived in 1897. If it was only her astral self that made the journey, why did she leave her clothes behind when she returned to 1969?

Tomorrow: Mesa of Lost Women.

859 dark shadows kitty edward shockd

Dark Shadows episode guide

— Danny Horn

20 thoughts on “Episode 859: If I Were You

  1. Good question about Julia’s clothes being left behind in 1897. I always wondered how Barnabas’ clothes were about to transform with his body into a bat and then untransform when he arrived at his destination.

    1. I wish Episode 859 had followed Julia back to 1969. Just for the one day- we’d have returned to 1897 on Friday, but it would have been nice to have a day when she’s talking with Stokes, Roger, and whoever else about what she saw in the nineteenth century and what’s been happening in while she’s been away. In general, I wish there were an episode a week or so during the 1897 segment when they reconnect us with the 1960s. If they had intercut the two time periods that way, they could have kept 1897 going for another year or two.

  2. “I know what I’d do if I suddenly looked like Quentin Collins, and I wouldn’t be wasting my time researching I Ching”

    Yes, I have to assume he built some time into his evil scheming schedule for playing with his new toy. I mean, you’d have to have the patience of a saint to leave something like that mint in the box.

    1. As far as I can tell, the only actress who hasn’t gotten to mack on Quentin 2.0 is Joan Bennett, the poor thing. I assume Kitty’s going to get a resounding smooch any second now.

  3. I think this starts a period where Grayson was off the show again for about a month. The ratings took a drop and I like to think it was because the core diehard fans who LIVED for her appearances got tired of waiting for her to come back. Of course the fact that Jon was out too no doubt had a great deal to do with it.

    I believe that this was the period when Grayson went off to do ADAM AT SIX A.M. with Mikey Douglas. Jon was doing DIAL M FOR MURDER somewhere in the Midwest.

  4. It’s the interchangeable Souls of the Davids! Characters played by David Selby, Thayer David, and David Henesy are easily possessed by each other.

  5. And I’ve noticed that the credits are still reading, “David Selby, Quentin Collins” and “Thayer David, Count Petofi” at the end. Maybe that’s the show’s way of illustrating that Quentin and Petofi are one and the same!

  6. Is this the episode where Nora plays passive-aggressive checkers with Kitty and the show does very odd extreme close-ups of the two actresses while they are talking?

    1. Denise was terrific as Suspicious Squirrel Nora in those scenes. You could tell she spotted a scheming golddigger governess out to snag a rich husband at fifty paces.

  7. The crack begins?

    I am not reading ahead in this blog. Just following, more or less, as I binge-watch a week or so of episodes. But I have been dreading the day when the world beyond this blog – in the election year of 2016 – would impinge on it with an unrivaled intensity. Yes, the world outside impinges all the time, but that has been a passing thing up until now. Today, I just read what I suspect to be the first crack, opening a new and potentially recurring impingement:

    “That’s often the case, that the people who endlessly brag about themselves are over-compensating for the inadequacies that they know only too well. That’s what makes them so spiteful, and dangerous. Luckily, there’s nobody of any importance in American public life who acts like that, so it’s not like it really matters.”

    Inevitable, perhaps, but I am writing three years hence (Long-running blogs are naturally a kind of space-time-warp continuum), and knowing in 2019 what early-2016 Danny does not yet know, I have to wonder how long it will be before Donald J. Trump comes to live rent free at DS Every Day.com, and how often we will encounter the new house-ghost-guest having a brandy in the drawing room at Collinwood. I can only hope that it is not too often, but I think I know too well what has become of my fellow Americans since 2016 to sustain such hope until I am proven right or wrong in my dread. The timelessness of DS – ironically or paradoxically or both – is that some passing outside influences don’t belong, however long it takes for them to pass.

    1. Yes, sitting here at the end of 2020 reading these little references to Don John of Astoria from 2015 and 2016 one does think of the proverbial black cloud on the horizon, no bigger than a man’s hand…

  8. I have to feel a little sorry for Thayer David. The whole plot right now is that nobody would want to look like him. They are even verbally disparaging his body. It’s downright mean.

    Also, one of those rare moments of sanity and realism occurred in yesterday’s episode (?). It was when the Reverend Trask pointed out that Edward was offering open-ended free room and board to anyone who knocked on the door. Trask was sensibly concerned about the bottom line operating budget of Collinwood. Edward, who’s main schtick is “the responsible one”, is a real hole in the pocket the Reverend has concluded. Actual household budgets exist? Was DS ever more down to earth than this?

    1. What got me was Trask complaining about allowing people to live rent free but he was the one who invited Amanda Harris to move in…Imagine that – hypocrisy from someone named Trask…

    2. I always found Thayer David delightful and attractive, especially as Professor Stokes, and he played Petofi as this “how? And yet…” charismatic lure-bait, so I really love how as Trapped Quentin, he manages to extinguish all that somehow.

  9. Denise Nickerson seems a bit more grounded in this episode, avoiding those overwrought reactions and line deliveries that have plagued her performance over the past several months.

  10. Kitty noticed Petofi’s ring when Quentin was wearing it. She said her husband had the exact same ring. The ring is on the Hand when Magda steals it from King Johnny. So are there multiple rings? Does the ring have a mind of its own like the Hand? Does it go flying off to have its own adventures when the box is closed only to reappear when an observer checks?

  11. That is strange that Julia’s 1969 outfit didn’t disappear with her. I would’ve thought her 1897 dress would’ve stayed. But this is Dark Shadows and there’s no use in trying to make sense.

    Denise Nickerson was very good in her scenes with KLS. I loved Lady Hampshire’s purple dress.

    That night ABC aired Bewitched episode #174: “Samantha’s Curious Cravings” where a pregnant Samantha starts zapping in any food she’s craving. When Dr. Bombay tries to cure her, she ends up popping to the location of where the food is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s