Episode 684: Barnabas Collins and the Mysterious Ghost

“Lots of things happen in this house that no one can understand.”

It always starts with a box.

You take your fears and your crimes and your regrets, and you bury them deep in the earth, and you tell yourself that no one will ever know. Nobody has a key, and nobody knows where you buried it, and nobody knows that it even exists. The mystery box is hidden forever.

But you know that it’s only a matter of time. Boxes open. That’s pretty much the whole point of boxes.

678 dark shadows quentin kids ghost

We’re currently three weeks away from Barnabas’ next time travel adventure, and the Dark Shadows writers are finally taking a moment to figure out what the hell they think they’re trying to accomplish.

For the last four months, Sam Hall and Ron Sproat have been engaged in a tug-of-war over the story direction. There are two ongoing stories right now — one fast and loud, the other slow and quiet — and so far, they haven’t quite managed to make it all fit together.

The Hall-style werewolf story has been barreling along, with lots of big fight scenes and plot twists. Barnabas had his first run-in with the creature on a Tuesday, and by Friday, he’d figured out who was responsible, and what he could do to help.

Meanwhile, the Sproat-style Turn of the Screw haunted house story has been meandering for two months, and so far, the only thing that anybody knows for sure is that David and Amy have been in kind of a weird mood lately.

Ron summed up the end of his Dark Shadows run in a 1990 interview with Edward Gross:

Ed:  There was a period after a while where nobody knew what the hell was going on.

Ron:  That’s right. We had arguments about that. I told Dan that I felt we owed a certain obligation to the person who isn’t able to get to the television every day, to explain what’s going on. That we should keep a fairly clear storyline. Fans didn’t want to have to have some sort of guide that would untangle all of this. They were in the process of straightening it out a bit, and I think it was going pretty well about the time of Quentin.

Ed:  But didn’t it start getting crazy again with Count Petofi and all of that?

Ron:  That was after I’d gone. I’d left when Quentin was lurking around.

And that says pretty much everything. As far as Ron is concerned, Quentin’s ghost is “lurking around”. They’ve said some words about who Quentin is and what he wants, but the clues have all been disconnected fragments that don’t add up to the character we’re going to meet next month. It’s mostly been lurking.

684 dark shadows chris beth woods

But yesterday, praise be, was Ron’s last episode, and now Sam is free to construct an actual storyline.

The most important item on the agenda is to connect the ghost story to the things that are actually working on the show — reluctant werewolf Chris, and the Junior Detectives team of Barnabas and Julia. The only game worth playing on Dark Shadows is Stand Next to Barnabas, and the ghosts have been lurking in the west wing for too long. If they want to stay on the show, they need to get on Barnabas’ radar.

So here comes Beth the ghost governess, appearing to Chris and leading him into the woods. She points to a spot on the ground, and then disappears. There are more direct ways to introduce yourself to people, but you know ghosts. They like to take the long way around.

684 dark shadows barnabas chris mystery box coffin

Chris brings Barnabas to the woods, and they dig in that spot, and they find the mystery box.

This is excellent news, because mystery boxes are always worth opening on Dark Shadows. Boxes, as everyone knows, are full of monsters and secrets.

Chris identifies this box as a child’s coffin, and naturally that means the best thing to do is break it open with a shovel and see what’s inside.

684 dark shadows barnabas chris grave robbing

They find the decaying corpse of an infant, and they pause for exactly four seconds before Chris says, “What’s that thing right there?” and Barnabas just reaches in and helps himself.

There really is a lot more grave-robbing on this show than your average afternoon soap opera. Chris has only been on the show for a few months, and already he’s taking to it like a duck to water.

684 dark shadows pentagram

There’s a necklace around the kid’s neck, and Barnabas just scoops it right up. Then they deliver some sensational dialogue:

Barnabas:  A pentagram!

Chris:  And with the two points downward.

Barnabas:  Someone here, long, long ago, needed protection, too. Protection from a… a werewolf!

Coming back from the opening titles, Chris asks, “Could it really mean that a werewolf existed around here before?” and Barnabas says, “That’s all it can mean,” and that’s that, mission accomplished. With that kind of logic, we’ll get these two stories connected in no time.

684 dark shadows david quentin mirror

Barnabas and Chris put the coffin back where they found it, minus one medallion, and they haven’t even had a chance to get back to the house when we see Quentin giving David some new instructions.

Now, I don’t want to keep bringing up Ron Sproat every five seconds, but this is a really good example of how much faster the show can be now. We just skipped over about three episodes of Sproat-style plot development in one quick cut.

If Ron wrote this sequence, we’d have one episode where Barnabas finds the pentagram and brings it home, a second episode where Amy notices the pentagram and asks Barnabas about it, and a third where Amy mentions the pentagram to Quentin. We could drag this plot point out for a whole week, if we really put our minds to it.

But today, Barnabas and Chris head back to the house, and then we cut straight to David saying, “No, I don’t want to do it, Quentin.” They didn’t even show him walking into the room; we just skip straight into the scene. Quentin wants David to bring him the pentagram, and he wants it by the end of act two.

This is what freedom from Sproat really means. At long last, Dark Shadows is acting like television.

684 dark shadows barnabas david darts

So I’m going to follow their example, and get to the point. Barnabas examines the pentagram with a magnifying glass, and David steals it while he’s not looking.

684 dark shadows quentin pentagram

David brings the pentagram to Quentin’s room in the west wing, and then something remarkable happens:

684 dark shadows quentin feeling 1

Quentin has a feeling.

684 dark shadows david quentin room

He clutches the pentagram in his fist, and for a moment, he just stands there and doesn’t look at anything.

David says, “You aren’t going to do anything terrible with it, are you, Quentin? You promised me that you wouldn’t.” But just for a moment, Quentin isn’t there.

684 dark shadows quentin feeling 2

Quentin doesn’t talk yet, and he hasn’t had much reason to. The kids do whatever he wants them to do, and most of the time, he’s just been — well, lurking, I guess.

But this is not lurking. This is something else.

684 dark shadows quentin glare

So far, we’ve seen a bunch of little clues about Quentin’s backstory, but most of them don’t matter, because they were written by Ron Sproat, and it was just talk anyway.

Speaking as Beth, Amy said, “You don’t believe in her powers. You don’t believe in her curse. But you should!” And David-as-Quentin replied, “Don’t worry. I’m tired of their interfering. I’m going to put it to an end.” In another episode, Roger found a note that said, “Dear Jamison, You must return to Collinwood. I need your help. You must intercede with Oscar. Only you can save me.”

But when it comes time to write the actual story, they don’t bother to sync up with those fragments, because this is a daily soap opera, and nobody’s going to remember it.

People have bad memories when it comes to exact words, but we’re pretty good at remembering props. So far, the important visuals have been the gramophone, the cradle, the skeleton in Quentin’s room, and now a child’s coffin with a pentagram inside. Those are the pieces that have to tie in with the time travel story, one way or another.

Quentin reacts to this pentagram because for the first time, he’s holding a clue that’s actually going to matter. The grim grinning ghost is finally allowed to feel something, and all of a sudden, Quentin Collins is real.

It’s nice to meet you, Quentin. Welcome to the show.

Tomorrow: A Fish Called Ezra.


The Ron Sproat interview quoted here is from Edward Gross’ Dark Shadows Tribute Book, published in 1990 by Pioneer Books. There’s a longer excerpt in a previous post, “The Last Days of Ron Sproat“.

Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

In the teaser, after opening the child’s coffin, Barnabas holds up the necklace with a pentagram on it — but he holds it so that it’s not facing the camera, and the audience can’t see the shape. When they come back from the opening titles, he’s turned the chain around so that the audience sees the pentagram.

There’s also a clatter from the studio in the middle of Barnabas’ “long, long ago” line.

In act 1, we see Quentin at the window much earlier than the intended reveal. I think this is the third time they’ve done that this week; they really need to get their heads around how to keep David Selby out of the shot.

Ezra tells Barnabas, “When I was young, there wasn’t anything I wanted to remember. But now that I do, there just doesn’t seem to be anything to remember.” I don’t know if that’s a line flub or not, but I can’t make heads or tails of it.

In the final scene, all of the clocks at Braithwaite’s are chiming, but the clock that the camera focuses on says it’s 7:26.

Abe Vigoda is credited as “Abe Vigodo.”

Behind the Scenes:

Judging from the mesh on the door and the window, Braithwaite’s shop is a redress of the police station set.

Ezra points out the “Smith Brothers” portrait of a man with a bushy mustache, and says it’s his father, Ezra Julius Braithwaite. That portait has been all over Collinsport; I think the last time we saw it was in Nicholas’ house.

Tomorrow: A Fish Called Ezra.

684 dark shadows rocket darts david

Dark Shadows episode guide

— Danny Horn

26 thoughts on “Episode 684: Barnabas Collins and the Mysterious Ghost

  1. Danny, when you are approaching 60, Ezra’s line about remembering will make better sense to you. Trust me on this.

  2. It’s ironic that Ron Sproat was forced to leave a show that was so popular with young people including teenagers, when previous to Dark Shadows he was writing for a soap aimed specifically at teenagers (Never Too Young, featuring Leave It to Beaver’s Tony Dow).

    It’s ironic how Sam Hall, who in later interviews couldn’t even remember the name of the renowned horror writer (Lovecraft) from whose work he would be sifting for possible story ideas at Dan Curtis’ insistence, was so successful in writing this kind of television when previously he could never have foreseen that he would be writing horror, as he’d had no real interest in the genre.

    It’s ironic how Dan Curtis can just walk in from a golf course to the world of daytime television and create and produce the most successful soap of all time with no previous experience in that particular area. Perhaps in the unconventional and uncharted territory he was mapping out, one really needed to be a fish out of water.

    It’s ironic how in 1969 and 1970 Abe Vigoda looked even older in his Dark Shadows appearances than he does in 2015. Talk about a Fish out of water.

  3. “When I was young, there wasn’t anything I wanted to remember. But now that I do, there just doesn’t seem to be anything to remember.”

    Maybe he meant: “When I was young, there wasn’t anything I wanted to remember. But now that there is, I just don’t seem to be able to remember.”

  4. I don’t know about you, but I wouldn’t believe anything a werewolf tells me over the phone…..

  5. It’s the old coffee mug joke. You know, the senior with CRS. I’m too close to that point to make light of it….

  6. The Quentin’s ghost storyline is starting to heat up now, about three weeks before 1897, and if you added all his and Beth’s relevant appearances prior to this point, it’s still barely a month. Compared next to the nine months of 1897, it’s barely a blip.

  7. The real tragedy of Sproat-style writing is that it still dominates serialised narrative in the year 2015, when we have access to recordable media, DVR, and YouTube.

    BTW this is one of my favourite episodes as well, generally spooky and lots of action.

  8. Love it when Caroline suggests that Chris was avoiding asking her out because he had “What might be called… other interests.”
    Is this 60s code do we think?

    Oh yeah and what’s up with Chris in the woods saying there must be a clue around there? As if an unmarked grave with a deaf baby and a pentagram was just normal?

  9. It is my opinion–and, I suspect, a nearly 100% objective fact–that the actress who plays Beth is extraordinarily attractive in appearance so this is by no means intended as an insulting observation, but would others here ever use the term “moonfaced” to describe her facial structure?

    I always used to assume that the term “moonfaced” describes those who have a profile like hers, with a distinctly pronounced and smoothly symmetrical chin and brow that (as captured well in the b&w image of her above) creates a crescent 🌙-shaped outline.

    And like any amateur astronomer, I love gazing at our beautiful moon so could never have imagined the “moonfaced” descriptor might be a slur.

    I only realized my mistake a few years ago when I complimented an acquaintance on his awesome, portrait-worthy moonface and another acquaintance later told me that it was an insult. (Obviously I am not the most socially “ept” person because I actually believed my intended flattery might precede an invitation to sketch this acquaintance sometime. ::sigh::).

    Anyway, I still think that term fitting for a truly, awesomely 🌙-like profile such as the Beth actress’s.

    )Ohhh! And the werewolves, Chris and Quentin, perhaps agree, finding themselves drawn to her profile, so alike to one of the safer and more attractive lunar phases, yes?)

  10. Barnabas’s transformation to junior detective is complete! Re: the magnifying glass (can’t seem to post a picture here).

    Blooper–The opening reprise is refilmed from the previous episode. In the previous episode, Chris was at first somewhat reluctant to open the child’s coffin. When Barnabas suggests it, Chris say, “Do you think we should?” In the refilmed reprise in this episode, Chris immediately gets the shovel with no hesitation when Barnabas suggests they open the coffin.

  11. I think Ezra’s line would make more sense if there was an emphasis on the last “to”:

    “When I was young, there wasn’t anything I wanted to remember. But now that I do, there just doesn’t seem to be anything TO remember…”

    Now that he actually wants to remember, he reaches back in his mind… And there’s nothing there. It’s quite sad, really.

    This episode is just full of beautiful little character moments – such a relief after all that personality-free Sproatalogue. The champagne scene is lovely, with Chris being happy and light and Carolyn delicately flirtatious, and I also like the moment when Carolyn recognises the jeweller’s mark – referencing a time David dropped the candlestick, and his surly response “you would remember that, wouldn’t you.” Just tiny little snippets that give the impression these are actual people with lives offscreen and separate personalities; that’s what writing character drama’s all about.

  12. Abe Vigoda! What a pleasant surprise! He already looked ancient here no doubt to the makeup, but still. He lived a great long life (96 years when he passed in 2016, about 11 months after this original post). I loved all the clocks in his shop.

    Quentin sure is creepy, never speaking, and always hanging out with the kids.

    This same night ABC aired Bewitched Episode 159: “Samantha the Sculptress” where Endora zaps up living busts of Darrin and Larry Tate in front of their client!

  13. Abe Vigoda ran marathons, and like many people who do that he had very little fat in his face. So he always looked old, even though he was in tremendous physical shape.

  14. “Barnabas: A pentagram!

    Chris: And with the two points downward.”

    A pentagram has one point downward. So if it has two points downward, isn’t that just a garden variety star? Funny that Barnabas goes directly to pentagram rather than lost Christmas ornament.

  15. When Carolyn is turning the lights out before going to bed, why doesn’t she close the window? She stands at it and looks outside, but leaves it open.

    1. Back in the 60s air conditioning was not that common. Installing it in a huge house like Collinwood would have been really expensive. Leaving the windows open made perfect sense.

      1. Makes sense in the real world, but when you live where there has been recent werewolf attacks I’d assume you’d apply any security you could.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s