Episode 414: That Thing You Do

“What have I become? How can I do things I do?”

Overall, it’s been a tough week for the women of Dark Shadows. Angelique was killed, Vicki’s in jail, and Josette probably shouldn’t be making any long-term plans.

1968 was the year they coined the phrase “Sisterhood Is Powerful”, which is good because these girls could use all the power they can muster. Today’s episode is practically a nature documentary about the lust, greed and hunger that’s making the pre-liberated ladies of Collinsport an endangered species.

414 dark shadows trapped sarah

For example, here’s young Sarah Collins, who’s being methodically stalked by the curse of a witch who actually died several days ago. Frustrated in love and perforated in the shoulder, Angelique cursed her wayward husband Barnabas, turning him into a vampire and decreeing that everyone who loves him will die.

Angelique is dead now herself, but the curse is still going strong, apparently powered by pure narrativium. In yesterday’s episode, Barnabas’ little sister Sarah was lighting a candle in Josette’s window, and saw her missing brother out on the lawn. Following him to the graveyard, she stumbled into the family mausoleum, where a magical gust of wind slammed the gate shut.

It’s hard to say exactly how the curse arranged all of this, because it had to line up a number of events simultaneously, starting with Riggs teaching Sarah how to make a candle. Unless Riggs is in on it. I’m not super familiar with how this kind of thing works.

414 dark shadows expect millicent nathan

Then we move to part two of today’s nature film, featuring bubble-headed heiress Millicent Collins, the eldest child of the New York branch of the family. While the rest of the family was occupied with other things, Millicent fell under the spell of the dashing, handsome and unscrupulous Lieutenant Nathan Forbes.

414 dark shadows mammal millicent nathan

Like the small mammals who ducked out of the way when the asteroid strike killed all the dinosaurs, Millicent has a good chance of surviving the ongoing Collins extinction event. Her natural-selection advantage is that she never stops talking, which is essential for soap opera characters. Also, she’s really funny.

Millicent:  I enjoyed the eclipse of the moon very much. It is something I shall tell my children —

She stops suddenly, realizing that she might be saying something presumptuous and improper.

Millicent:  I mean — so few people see eclipses. So few people are up this late. I mean, people one knows. I understand that other people stay up later, somehow. Good night.

Nathan:  I’m staying for a few minutes.

Millicent:  Oh, no, no — you mustn’t. Remember the night cousin Barnabas discovered you here so late?

Nathan:  Yes, well, he’s on his way to England now.

Millicent:  Yes. An odd fact in itself. I mean, he never mentioned his going, and I saw him just a day or two before. To leave for England in the middle of the night… Wasn’t it lucky there was a ship!

She’s fantastic. I adore Millicent, as do all right-thinking people. It’s a Sam Hall script today, and you can tell, because it’s witty and the B-plot is even more entertaining than the A-plot.

414 dark shadows hunter millicent nathan

Nathan is watching Millicent like a hunter stalking his prey. He’s been at this for a little while, and he knows exactly how to tease and flatter her into striking range.

Millicent:  I think you frighten me, sir.

Nathan:  Oh well, then, tell me how, and I will stop.

414 dark shadows eclipse millicent nathan

He leads her over to the couch.

Millicent:  Oh, no, please don’t! I — I mean… you make me do things I should not do.

Nathan:  Like watching the eclipse?

Millicent:  Yes. I realize it is not your fault that eclipses occur late at night. It’s… it’s what you make me do that frightens me.

414 dark shadows married millicent nathan

He leans back, and baits the hook.

Nathan:  Well, you could be slightly more modern in your approach to life. Ah, but then I expect you’ll learn to be. After we’re married.

414 dark shadows hook millicent nathan

And there you have it; she’s done. At this point, all he has to do is come up with a plausible rationale for why he plans to quit the Navy and live off her money.

By the way, with Barnabas and Jeremiah dead, and Sarah trapped all night in a drafty mausoleum, it turns out that this is the future of the Collins family. That problem kind of snuck up on us while we weren’t looking.

414 dark shadows virtue ruby

Which takes us to stage three of Dark Shadows’ war on women. The bored-looking young lady in the red dress and the feathery hat is Ruby Tate, a woman of uncertain virtue spending a quiet night out on the docks.

414 dark shadows fog barnabas ruby

She spots a dim figure in the distance, and calls out to him, thinking it’s a regular client.

But something else steps out of the fog.

414 dark shadows ripper barnabas ruby

So now we’ve got another one of those Sam Hall narrative collisions, where he takes a different story and drops it into the show, just to see what happens. In this case, it’s Jack the Ripper, the notorious serial killer who slaughtered prostitutes in Whitechapel.

This is another anachronism, obviously, because they never do anything else. The 1795 storyline is taking inspiration from both the 1690s Salem witch trials and the 1880s Jack the Ripper murders, which is kind of like setting a story in World War I, featuring guest appearances by George Washington and Neil Armstrong.

But as always with the narrative collisions, you can’t fight the power of combining these images. A dark, foggy night, a streetwalker and a guy in a cape with a twisted need for blood; there’s only one place this is going.

414 dark shadows jack the ripper

Just to trace the inspiration a little more specifically, this is how the 1959 film Jack the Ripper starts out — a tipsy prostitute stumbling home in the fog, guy in a cape gets busy with the knife. This was actually the first film to dress Jack up in a top hat and cape, turning him into a cultured aristocrat. This in turn was inspired by the 1958 Hammer horror film Dracula, and at some point you can probably trace it all back to Bela Lugosi, just like everything else on Dark Shadows.

By the way, note the feathery hat on this girl. Those must be bad luck or something.

414 dark shadows ntural barnabas ruby

Anyway, let’s get back to Ruby, who doesn’t have a lot of time to waste at this point. Unfortunately, she makes what must be a n00b mistake for a lady of the evening, namely: recognizing your prospective client. Barnabas is the heir to the most important family in town, and Ruby coos over how delighted she is to meet him.

She keeps saying, “Wait until I tell the girls at the Eagle about this!” and generally does everything she can to shorten her projected life span every time she opens her mouth.

414 dark shadows stir ruby barnabas

Amazingly, Barnabas still thinks he can pull back from what he’s about to do. But she’s a pro in the temptation industry, and he can’t resist playing with his food.

Barnabas:  I really should be going.

Ruby:  Oh, c’mon, you don’t want to go now, do you?

Barnabas:  It’s what I should do.

Ruby:  Well… don’t do things you should do. That’s the way I live my life. You should try it.

414 dark shadows wind-up barnabas ruby

Barnabas decides to take her advice, but he’s a newbie in this area too, and he botches it. He takes too long in the wind-up, giving her time to pull away.

414 dark shadows back barnabas ruby

Then they do something peculiar. Realizing that Barnabas is the guy who’s been attacking women around town, she backs away — and falls off the dock, into the water.

And Barnabas just stands there on the dock, watching her drown.

414 dark shadows watch barnabas

So this is a dark place for the narrative to go, because this scene — and many like it to come, over the course of the series — is based on the idea that prostitutes are expendable.

In the early days of Barnabas’ storyline in 1967, when Barnabas was fully positioned as a villain, people talked about all the attacks on girls in town. We didn’t see those girls, apart from Maggie, and there was no mention that they were anything other than normal, law-abiding citizens.

But now, when the story is going in the direction of “I can’t help it, I need blood in order to survive,” the victims have to be prostitutes, because the audience is much more likely to accept those deaths with a shrug.

Having her die by falling in the water is also expected to cushion things for the audience, as if her death wasn’t entirely Barnabas’ fault. It’s actually kind of a comedy ending for the scene, with a funny pratfall as a tag.

414 dark shadows face ruby

We’re not really expected to care about the death of this young woman. We don’t see her take her last breath, and we don’t see anyone grieve for her. She’s a fallen woman, and once she falls, we’re done with her.

Obviously, some of that is just the difference between a minor role and a regular character like Sarah or Josette, but that’s class-based as well. The show focuses on the happiness and tragedy of the richest family in town. Lower-class people like Ruby are just the day-players, and we can murder them whenever we feel like it.

Like I said, it’s been a rough week for women on Dark Shadows, and I get the feeling there’s more of the same coming up. Females of Collinsport — you might want to consider taking an alternate route to work in the morning. It’s a jungle out there.

Tomorrow: Closing the Loop.

Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

Nathan assures Millicent that he can leave his Navy post, saying, “I’m not promised to them to life — for life.”

In act 2, Naomi forgets whether Vicki is singular or plural.

Millicent:  Miss Winters is very, very cruel.

Naomi:  No. Miss Winters were telling me so we could stop it from happening.

When Barnabas approaches Ruby on the wharf, the fog machine starts making horrible cranking noises. This lasts throughout the scene.

Behind the Scenes:

Ruby Tate was played by Elaine Hyman, in her only Dark Shadows appearance. She’d previously been on TV in East Side/West Side in 1964. She also played a role in a 1974 episode of the anthology show The Wide World of Mystery, in an episode called “The Spy Who Returned From the Dead”. In 1975, she appeared in the Broadway production of Alan Ayckbourn’s interlinked trilogy The Norman Conquests.

Hyman returned to TV in 2002, when she was 68 years old, to play roles on The Sopranos, Broad City and several Law & Order series. She’s got a small part in a James Franco movie, Black Dog/Red Dog, that’s currently in post-production. A few weeks from the day this is posted, she’ll celebrate her 80th birthday.

We’ll see Ruby’s ghost in June; in that appearance, she’ll be played by Natalie Norwich.

Yesterday, a date in the Collins family history book established that the last half of this week’s episodes are taking place from January 24-26, 1796. Coincidentally, there was actually a penumbral lunar eclipse on January 24, 1796, but it was invisible to the naked eye.

Also, there wasn’t a good place to write this in the post, but when Millicent and Nathan are in the woods searching for Sarah, they hear dogs howl. In the show’s chronology, this is the earliest example of Barnabas inspiring dognoise. We’ll hear some more tomorrow.

Tomorrow: Closing the Loop.

414 dark shadows jungle barnabas ruby

Dark Shadows episode guide

— Danny Horn

27 thoughts on “Episode 414: That Thing You Do

  1. In regards to the 1967 victims I was confused as to how Barnabas originally procured and attacked these girls -did he ‘team up’ with Willy and have Willy grab the girl so Barnabas can then proceed to bite her – it sounded like most of the girls managed to get away without being bitten so I assumed Willy bungled his part of the job – also Barnabas originally slaughtered cows and calves for nourishment (in the ‘Twilight’ style but apparently ‘vegetanarism’ wasn’t for him). Another puzzling issue is how did Barnabas continue to keep Willy under his control – did he have to bite him on a regular basis like he did when he needed to keep Maggie in line?

    1. They were highly inconsistent about the feeding habits of vampires, and how fatal they were (we get to see other vampires who usually did NOT kill on the first feeding – maybe with time yes, but not immediately). Also there is only mention of “attacks” without specifying the outcome (so in 1970 when Maggie is attacked again, and she is in bed, Carolyn talks about similar attacks one year ago).

      Of course in Barnabas’ case we are dealing with someone whose solution to any problem is “kill someone”, so he cannot be seen as a typical anything…

      (It is noticed that in PT there are no mention of any attacks, nor when they come back… so I figure that by then Barnabas had learned how to fly under the radar – starting with Buffy Harrington).

    2. Maybe Barnabas was able to sorta hypnotize his female victims, either with his vampiric powers or his dark good looks (love that last screenshot!) or a combination of the two. This is from a girl who’s always had a crush on (Jonathan Frid’s) Barnabas Collins, however. 😉

  2. Oh, the inconsistencies with Barnabas’s powers and abilities.

    After he bites Carolyn, he tells Julia that she couldn’t “betray me if she wanted to.” OK. That seems somewhat in line with how Willie was depicted. He never killed Barnabas during the day and was so much under his power, he couldn’t just jump in the car and drive away.

    But when Willie is shot, Barnabas and Julia are both concerned that Willie will rat them out. But why? What changed everything? And Maggie had to be hypnotized to forget rather than simply being as much under Barnbas’s power as Willie.

    It is also uncertain that Barnabas actually needs to drink blood to survive. He is depicted as being compelled or driven to do so, but is he just a white-knuckling alcoholic? That’s how it seems after 1967 (1897, 1970, 1840).

    1. I guess deciding where he does need it, means going to the definition of vampire… As far as I can recall vampires cannot eat normal food, so for them it is blood or nothing….

      Reminds me of Saberhagen’s Dracula “Try doing without food for a week, without water for a day, without air for a minute.”

  3. i was wondering why barnabas didnt help ruby, seeing as he called her name and looked genuinely horrified when she fell. cant vampires swim?

    1. Since a few minutes later we see that Barnabas is once again obviously just post-feeding, the implication is that he “helped” her and then helped himself. Unless he went and found another victim after this one floated out of reach.

    2. Running water is supposedly fatal to vampires isn’t it? (maybe I’m wrong, or misremembering, but I’m pretty sure). I don’t know if the sea counts as “running” particularly, but it is moving, so… Could be that.
      Could also be that Barnabas was wearing an expensive ensemble and didn’t want to ruin it with sea water just in order to help some random prostitute. He’s kinda selfish like that.

  4. The scene at the end when Sara sees Barnabas just after he’s fed was heartbreaking. I thought JF did some great acting there — the tragedy of Barnabas’s situation came through loud and clear.

  5. We see the same idea about prostitutes being disposable in “The Godfather II.” Our protagonist , Michael, is supposed to be relatively sympathetic. He got in to save his father and family. Generally the people he kills deserve it or are worse than he is. But when the senator needs to be induced to play ball, they arrange to have him wake up with a dead hooker. Michael dismisses her death as trivial because she has no family. No one will miss her. People expressed outrage over his murder of Fredo, but no one ever brings up that nameless woman who is killed so Michael can get the senator to approve a liquor license without paying an exorbitant fee. I guess we have a dollar value as to how much her life was worth.

  6. That disinterest in the life of a prostitute is in part key to our fascination with Jack the Ripper because the crime and criminal loom large, but the victims are more like props. And that’s precisely what today’s victim is doing for Barnabas. This is why Allan Moore’s “Lost Girls” focuses so much on the women who would be the ripper’s victim, as a kind of corrective to the myth.

    (Although I have to point out how good this actress is and really puts a lot of Victorian charisma into this time traveling prostitute.)

  7. Great screencaps of Lt. Forbes pouring on the charm! Looks like they did some costume alterations, I seem to recall that his breeches were a bit more ‘snug’ previously. Maybe he’s wearing his “fat” pants?

  8. This is one of those absolute show-stopping episodes primarily because of the insertion of the harlot and “loose woman about town” Ruby Tate. Part Jack the Ripper, part Dickensian street wench, another incredible decision by the writers to give us a taste of what Barnabas’ new life is all about. And we are riveted by it, pulled in and nailed to the screen. This is yet another ground-breaking and edgy scenes that seems unthinkable for 1968 television and yet here it is.

    1. I agree, Barry. Because of this scene’s edginess and its Jack the Ripper flavor, it’s one of the most memorable 1795 ID S episodes.

  9. I spoke too soon. Bstnsbsd a so back to wearing a white cravat in this and the next one, and is back to the black one tomorrow night–and THEN will to that color the rest of the way.

  10. I spoke too soon. Barnabas is back to the white cravat in this and in the next episode, and THEN will be back to the black one for the rest of the way. I think he wore the white one when the writers wanted to add some mild gore that would look more vivid through contrast with a white rather than a black garmet.

  11. First of all, I want to say thank you for these wonderful and very entertaining plot summaries. I can’t begin to imagine how much time and effort you’re putting into this project!

    I’m one of those original fans of the show who used to rush home from school at 10 years old to watch daily on the family’s old black and white TV in the basement. I started watching clips on YouTube recently after being very disappointed trying to watch the early 90s remake on Prime.

    Shortly thereafter I began watching the original series and gave up on the bland turtleneck remake immediately. Not long after that, I discovered you’re wonderful series of episodic blog posts which I have appreciated greatly as a companion to my reacquaintance with the show that I remembered from so long ago.

    Among other things, I always check the blooper section at the end of each entry make sure I caught them all!

    With all of that out of the way, now here is the second purpose of my comment, which is to ask the following question:

    Does this episode mark the very first appearance of the classic Barnabas wolf’s head cane in the 1795 storyline?

    I don’t recall seeing him with it prior to this in 1795. I kept wondering when it was going to appear and I was expecting some sort of explanation or origin for it, but apparently it just shows up with no back story at all.

    Have I missed something?

        1. Sure thing, Ricardo–and I’m so glad we and a few others have been able to contribute to this wonderful blog during 2020.

  12. “Naomi: No. Miss Winters were telling me so we could stop it from happening.”

    Sorry, I heard “was.” Perhaps Joan Bennett didn’t say it as clearly as she could have, but then I don’t look for bloopers where none exist.

  13. Ms. Hyman gave one of the best one-off performances in the series. But poor Ruby – didn’t anyone tell her “don’t take your love to town”?

  14. Correct me if I am wrong, but has anyone else noticed that Barnabas didn’t use that wolf’s head cane until very recently in the 1795 story arc? Like post-vampire. Maybe I wasn’t paying attention. It becomes a big prop down the road. It’s shown in his portrait that hangs in the 1960’s Collinwood entry, yet I don’t recall seeing it in the early going of 1795. It seemed to have materialized with him in his coffin.

  15. Another blooper I noticed: Millicent’s hair begins to fall into her face during her conversation with Naomi about Sarah being outside. I wondered if there was a hair person standing just off camera at the ready with a bobbi pin and some Aqua Net? Nowadays, we would cut and spend the next 20 minutes getting Hair to come fix the do. But not with DS, where we are live to tape and the show must go on. When we see Millicent next in the woods with Nathan, her hair is all fixed and looking picture perfect! Good job Hair Department! Way to hustle!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s