Episode 246: Family Planning

“Well, I’ve got some news for you. Either your mother has taken leave of her senses, or I have.”

Well, we should’ve seen it coming. On Friday, we had too much fun with the vampire, switching blood slides and generally getting up to mischief, so today we’re back in detention with Liz and Jason.

246 dark shadows dooracting richard garner

This is the blackmail storyline, so we’ve got all the time in the world for a nice big chunk of door acting. Liz is pacing in the drawing room, there’s a knock at the door, and she walks all the way across the set to open it. It’s Richard Garner, exactly who she was expecting, and there’s some business with his hat and coat.

Carolyn watches Liz and Richard walk into the drawing room, and then Vicki has to enter through another door before anybody can actually talk to each other.

All in all, I make it 75 seconds before the first character says a single line of non-door-related dialogue. I don’t know if that’s a record, but it’s certainly the time to beat.

246 dark shadows garner liz

So here’s the bad news: Richard Garner is Liz’s lawyer, and he’s here to explain to us how divorce works.

The good news: This is his last appearance, and we’ll never see another boring lawyer, banker or cannery union representative for the rest of the series. The next new character they introduce is a make-believe comedy beatnik. After that, there’s a ghost, and a mad scientist, and then we’re off to the races.

Liz tells Garner that she wants to get a divorce. Her husband Paul “disappeared” 18 years ago, and the lawyer’s been urging Liz to divorce him for years.

He says that the divorce will be easy, given Paul’s desertion; they ought to be able to do it in 90 days, perhaps sooner. And it had better be a lot sooner, because I personally have zero interest in watching people sit around and talk about it for another three months.

246 dark shadows liz roger

Liz tells her brother Roger about the divorce, and he’s thrilled; he uses the word “delighted” three times. Everybody in today’s episode acts like this is the best news they’ve heard in years.

He puts his arm around her, and says, “Well, we didn’t have much luck with marriage, did we? Either one of us. Perhaps we’re people who were never meant to be married.”

And that’s one reason why there are so many gay Dark Shadows fans.

For the most part, soap operas are a long series of heterosexual love stories, punctuated by the occasional murder. Dark Shadows has its share of romance and passion, especially once we get into Barnabas’ backstory, but the romance is usually either tragic or unrequited. There’s a lot of longing for people that you love desperately, but you can’t have.

In fact, there’s only one happily married couple in the entire series, and it’s Sandor and Magda, two traveling gypsies and con artists that we meet in 1969.

246 dark shadows ralston purina lamp

Have you noticed that I’m mentioning a lot of future storylines today? That’s because the alternative is actually writing about this episode, which is impossible.

So let’s move along. Liz tells Roger that she’s considering marrying again. Roger, Carolyn and Vicki confer in the library, and they decide that Jason must have some hold over Liz.

Carolyn finally remembers that she was trying to get into That Room in the Basement a few weeks ago, and now she’s determined to get down there and see what the big secret is all about. Liz refuses to give Carolyn the key, and that pretty much wraps it up.

And now, the really good news: we will be going down into the basement tomorrow, but not the Collinwood basement. Instead, we’ll visit the Old House basement, where there’s an undead ghoul lying in a coffin. Hooray!

Tomorrow: I’m Someone Else.


Dark Shadows bloopers to watch out for:

The camera pans across the foyer in the opening scene. As we get to the drawing room doors, the camera’s focus is too high, revealing the studio lights above the top of the set.

When Vicki and Carolyn talk in the foyer, there’s a huge shadow from the camera on Carolyn’s back.

Roger says “either your mother has taken leave of her senses, or I have” at two different points during the library scene. He realizes that he’s repeating himself halfway through the line, but by that point, he’s committed to it.

When Carolyn walks into the drawing room to confront Liz, the camera jumps a little bit, as if it’s startled.


Behind the Scenes:

This episode is the last appearance of lawyer Richard Garner, played by Hugh Franklin. Garner appeared in six Dark Shadows episodes, starting in November 1966, and he represented Roger when he was accused of killing Bill Malloy. The character’s biggest impact on the show was that he introduced his tedious son, Frank Garner, who appeared in 19 episodes as a possible love interest for Vicki.

Franklin was a Broadway actor in the 1940s who transitioned to television in the 50s, appearing on a few anthology shows and taking small parts on the soap operas Love of Life and As the World Turns.

After Dark Shadows, Garner played Dr. Charles Tyler, part of the original cast of All My Children, and he stayed with the soap from 1968 to 1981. Dr. Tyler’s on-screen wife, Phoebe, later married Langley Wallingford, played by Louis Edmonds (Dark Shadows’ Roger).

One more trivia fact about Hugh Franklin: He was married to novelist Madeline L’Engle, who wrote the children’s science-fiction classic A Wrinkle in Time. There, I’m done.

Tomorrow: I’m Someone Else.

246 dark shadows jason liz

Dark Shadows episode guide – 1967

— Danny Horn

10 thoughts on “Episode 246: Family Planning

  1. Danny — Thanks for the Hugh Franklin backgrounder. I had no idea about his marriage.

    I always enjoyed the Dr. Tyler / Phoebe / Mona storyline during the late ’70s. Perhaps the best triangle ever on a soap of three characters “of a certain age.”

  2. Not quite the last lawyer–what about Peter Bradford? Though I suppose you have to put quotation marks around “lawyer” for him.

  3. All My Children premiered in 1970. I think you have the year confused with One Life to Live, another Agnes Nixon creation which did premiere in 1968.

  4. Charles Dawson and Desmond Collins act as attorneys in the 1840s trial storyline; but I’d prefer to see their credentials before calling them lawyers.

  5. My jaw dropped when Mr. Garner just laid his coat on Carolyn’s shoulder. And Carolyn didn’t even bat an eye. I knew women were expected to be home-makers or secretaries in the sixties, but coat-hangers?

    1. I noticed that too, Jay, but it looked to me like Carolyn grinned a little. Made me think that Garner’s known her since she was a little girl and probably teases her with gestures like that.

      1. Good point, Mike. And I don’t remember if they’d still not put up any coat hooks by the door yet, so any table or shoulder was probably fair game!

  6. Yes, gay people love Dark Shadows, because we could relate to the whole unrequited love riff, but also the part about having to always cover the deep dark secret. Of course I don’t view it that way now, but back in the Dark Shadows timeline of my life I completely understood Barnabas in the closet. Plus, there was usually some hottie to crush on on both sides of the spectrum.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s